BOSTON — A woman who as a teenager encouraged her suicidal boyfriend to kill himself may have made bad choices but did not commit a crime, her lawyer told Massachusetts’ highest court on Thursday. Attorney Daniel Marx said Michelle Carter, now 22, was a misguided teen who was struggling with her own issues and had been trying to help Conrad Roy III. He said Roy was committed to ending his life and was responsible for his own death.
“We can all see from the text messages that Michelle Carter did not force Conrad Roy to kill himself,” Marx told the Supreme Judicial Court. “It was a tragic decision that he made.”
Carter wasin a trial last year that drew international attention due to the thorny legal questions and the insistent tone of her text messages to her boyfriend. “48 Hours” investigated the case in the episode
The day Roy filled his truck with carbon monoxide in a Fairhaven, Massachusetts, store parking lot, then-17-year-old Carter texted him: “You keep pushing it off and say you’ll do it but u never do. It’s always gonna be that way if u don’t take action.”
In convicting Carter, the judge, however, focused on how she told Roy to “get back in” after he climbed out of his truck as it was filling with the toxic gas and told her he was scared. The judge said Carter had a duty to call the police or Roy’s family when she knew he was killing himself.
But the only evidence Carter instructed Roy to get back in the truck was a long, rambling text she sent to a friend two months later in which she called Roy’s death her fault, Marx said. He also said there is no evidence Roy’s life would have been saved if Carter had called for help.
At Carter’s June 2017 trial, a psychiatrist testified Carter too wasand at first tried to talk Roy out of it, but became convinced she needed to help Roy “get to heaven” only after he convinced her there was nothing she could do to stop him.
Prosecutors, however, say Carter pushed Roy over the edge, noting he had tried to kill himself several times before and backed out.
Assistant District Attorney Shoshana Stern told the court that Carter knew she had “significant leverage” over Roy and became more insistent as he became more depressed. On the day of his death, Carter threatened that she was going to get him help if he didn’t go through with his plan, Stern said.
“She knew he was terrified of ending up in the hospital and disappointing his family,” Stern said.
Prosecutors argued at trial that Carter pushed Roy to commit suicide because she was desperate for attention and sympathy from classmates, and wanted to play the role of a grieving girlfriend.
Carter wasbut has remained free on supervised release while she pursues her appeal. At her August 2017 sentencing hearing, Conrad Roy Jr., Roy’s father, called his son his “best friend” and “first mate.”
“Although he did have some psychological troubles, we all felt he was going in the right direction and over the worst of it,” Roy said.
He said Michelle Carter has not shown any remorse and said she “exploited my son’s weaknesses and used him as a pawn in her own well-being.”
“Where is her humanity? In what world is this behavior OK and acceptable?” Roy said.
In a June 2017 interview with “48 Hours,” Roy’s mother Lynn Roy said she doesn’t believe Carter “has a conscience.”
“I think she needs to be held responsible for her actions ’cause she knew exactly what she was doing and what she said,” Roy told Erin Moriarty.
This is the second time Carter’s case is before the state’s high court. The court ruled in 2016 that Carter had to face trial, saying the grand jury was justified in indicting her with involuntary manslaughter.
The court is expected to rule in the coming months. When asked whether they would appeal the case to the U.S. Supreme Court if the justices don’t rule in Carter’s favor, Joseph Cataldo, another one of her attorneys, said they would consider all of their options.
© 2018 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.